The
chapter, “Toward a Balanced Diet of Reading”, was interesting and made me think
about the kinds of reading materials I want to offer my students in the future.
What I found really interesting was the section on David Bodanis’ book A Biography of the World’s Most Famous
Equation. I do think it can hard for students to fully understand complex
concepts, such as Einstein’s equation, by just reading a few paragraphs in a
textbook. Also, if they do understand what they read, it sometimes is only for
the assessment they’ll have in that class. Bodanis’ book elaborated on
Einstein’s equation and told a story behind what each component of the
equation. In this chapter, the authors describe this book as being very
engaging and informative. I believe that this is more important because
students usually remember topics and concepts that grabbed their attention.
This book is also described as a “page-turner”. I would think students will
remember something that they wanted to read rather than a textbook they are assigned
that can sometimes be confusing or boring. If a teacher does assign these kinds
of readings to their students they will have to make the time for the student
to read more. I still think reading a more engaging book on one important
concept is more beneficial to the student rather than reading a textbook that
may not get the whole picture across.
Another
component that I liked about this chapter and that I still question is, what is
a balanced diet of reading? As a future teacher, I would like to learn more
about what I should assign as readings in my classroom as I obviously would
want my students to want to read and to actually read the material assigned.
The author went off of two theories about what students should be reading. One
was a more classic list that included books that were much older and the other
was a list of more modern books. I think I would like to assign some of both,
but carefully choose the texts from both areas to make sure they are engaging
to my students. I still would like to do some more research on what is more
successful in a secondary education classroom.
My
favorite part of the chapter was the section on building a classroom library. I
found this part to be interesting because it is something that I did not see in
the majority of my high school classrooms but I do think it could be very
useful to students. A classroom library provides easy access to different kinds
of reading material. Also, it is something teachers don’t have to spend too
much money on and if they buy a few books/magazines/etc. each year the cost of
the materials might not seem so bad. I think it is good for students because they can choose what
to read and they can use it as references for research papers or lab reports.
Also, having books such as the Guinness Book of World Records can provide the
students with little facts to broaden their knowledge base. A classroom library
is definitely something I would also like to look into and use in the future.

Hey Tiffany,
ReplyDeleteTwo things stood out to me from you response to Chapter 4. One of them was, "If a teacher does assign these kinds of readings to their students they will have to make the time for the student to read more." Yes, there needs to be more time to cover a book of the length that was mentioned in the reading. The thing is that not all books are as straight forward with ideas like the book that was mentioned. I think it really comes down to how the teacher uses the time, whether it be time for reading or time for discussion, the time elapsed needs to be sure efficiently.
The second: "I still think reading a more engaging book on one important concept is more beneficial to the student rather than reading a textbook that may not get the whole picture across." The use of a reference that is engaging is a great thing but then again the point needs to be clear. The students should know what they are leaving with. It makes me think about the reggeaton artist's song that was used in the Spanish class I observed last time I was at CF High. It might be appealing but there was nothing concrete to learn. Maybe there was if the teacher made it evident. The reggeaton that the artist does sing about is the truth about life and he presents great ideas but, his ideas need guidance by a teacher in order to reach the students. The students cannot decipher the music on their own. But yeah, it's all on how the teacher uses the resources.
Sorry for typing so much, thanks for reading.
-Adrián
Hi Tiff,
ReplyDeleteI had to reread this passage from your post multiple times, "Also, if they do understand what they read, it sometimes is only for the assessment they’ll have in that class." This is what I kept coming back to as I finished reading your post. I completely agree. I remember in high school when I had to study for a test in physics or a math class and I would study so much to understand a single concept that I would forget about soon after the test. One must be engaged and have a connection to the reading so that it sticks with them for longer than just an assignment period. By creating this balance of textbooks and other material, a teacher can find ways to keep the students engaged, learning, and retaining information.